The West Mifflin Athletic Hall of Fame honors individuals and teams whose commitment, dedication, and excellence have brought pride and distinction to West Mifflin High School and the surrounding community. Open to athletes, coaches, teams, and contributors, eligibility requires that nominees be graduates of West Mifflin High School—or its predecessor schools—who have been out of school for at least 10 years, and who have lived lives marked by strong moral character, public service, and a spirit of goodwill. Candidates are evaluated based on accomplishments that include national, state, or local recognition during their high school careers, significant contributions to athletics, and unique achievements that elevated the school's reputation. Each year, up to ten inductees are selected and honored at a formal banquet and recognized during a West Mifflin home football game.